A tale of vengeance weaved by the Joker who relates Poison Ivy going after the real estate developers that were destroying the land when she first got her powers.
- 70
Comics Bulletin
Despite it's weaknesses, this is a fun book! Emphasis on fun! It's nothing especially substantial but it's a nice light snack. So sit down in your most comfortable chair with your favorite beverage and sink your teeth into this fanciful Tale from the Crypt, uhm I mean Joker's Asylum. - 50
IGN
In the end, this third one-shot in the Joker's Asylum mini is largely forgettable, and will likely dissapear into the vast pool of bargain Batman one-shots found in any convention long box. - 20
ComicBookBin
Aside from this morally-primitive storyline, this issue fails to create any horror or suspense. You can practically see everything coming a mile away which only serves to make Batman look even dumber. Well, maybe people were getting tired of the all-mighty uber-Bat but this is really a poor showing for any heroic character. The art is also rather uninspired. The only time it perks up is when it comes to showing cheesecake shots of Poison Ivy-- which just cements the fact that this book is intended to make her look good.